Sunday Reflection / Comparison / After & Before Discussion – Withered Hand

On 7 March, 2010 by slowcoustic

mirrored

Two sides of the same coin. Six of one, half dozen of the other. You know what I am getting at, two versions of one artist’s music. For fans, it can be both genre “eye-opening” such as this one might be or create a polarization of those that have give someone a sound they are most comfortable with.

Okay, let’s just get it out there that I am a “folkie”, so this post is a reference to Withered Hand releasing a “dance” remix of “Love in the Time Ecstasy” so I might be biased. Regardless, for some it is just more output from an artist and if they are a fan, this is often a good thing. For others, when artists experiment (or hell, this example could be the real Withered Hand, I wouldn’t know) they feel almost betrayed as it isn’t the artist they thought they knew. This post is a scenario of essentially a fringe folk type releasing a pseudo dance track. This probably would never, ever, ever have happened prior to the “mash up/remix” craze that affects the music scene today, but we can’t reverse the evolution of music now can we? So where to we stand? Let’s take a listen shall we.

No CigarettesWithered Hand
“Love in the Time Ecstacy (Swimmer One Remix) (mp3)
from “No Cigarettes”
(SL Records)

More On This Album

~~

You're Not AloneWithered Hand
“No Cigarettes” (mp3)
from “You’re Not Alone”
(SL Records)

Buy at iTunes Music Store
More On This Album
~~

Just so we are clear, the above two songs are now together on this new single release as “No Cigarettes” is re-released from You’re Not Alone as the b-side to the remix. So? Do you feel like this is an evolution of an artist, a side diversion of an artist or simply something he did one day and thought it turned out pretty good (or the re-mixers did a good job and he thought it was worthy)? I obviously like the old school Withered Hand, but that is no surprise due to my limited tunnel vision (is that an oxymoron?). I don’t think the SL Records remix is bad, but it feels like something Bronski Beat would have released in the early 80s. Maybe it is another option to get more notice for Withered Hand…not a bad thing, but is it necessary?

What do you think?

~Smansmith

5 Responses to “Sunday Reflection / Comparison / After & Before Discussion – Withered Hand”

  • Never ever ever did I think I’d see the words ‘Withered Hand’ and ‘remix’ in the same post!

    Downloading so I can listen later – I’ll let you know!

  • slowcoustic

    @Agnes, no kidding! Let us know if ya like it.

    Also, I just heard from Hamish with Swimmer One and apparently IODA had it tagged incorrect and it is NOT “Swimmer Me Remix” but actually “Swimmer One remix”. Sorry to the boys at Swimmer One – it is corrected on my end now!

    ~S

  • If you don’t like Swimmer One’s mix you’ll probably not enjoy Wowl!’s take on New Dawn – you can hear it at slrecords.net about half way down the main page.
    I know that they’re not gonna be everyone’s cup of tea – I dunno how keen Dan WH is on them – but I think they’re both rather tasty (which is why I’ve made them available). It’s interesting to hear other people’s takes on the songs.
    They’re not really a part of the evolution of Withered Hand’s sounds – more some interesting (or not so interesting depending on your point of view) asides.

  • Agnes

    So I’ve had a listen, and I’m afraid it’s a resounding no from me.

    You can’t mess with the Withered Hand, man!

Trackbacks & Pings

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Please leave these two fields as-is:

Protected by Invisible Defender.